Singer solution to world poverty essays

The child is killed.

The singer solution to world poverty citation

But one doesn't need to embrace my utilitarian ethic to see that, at the very least, there is a troubling incongruity in being so quick to condemn Dora for taking the child to the organ peddlers while, at the same time, not regarding the American consumer's behavior as raising a serious moral issue. Bob now has a choice. But then he reminds us that we, too, have opportunities to save the lives of children. Nobody who knows the world of overseas aid can doubt that such uncertainties exist. To answer this question affirmatively is to endorse follow-the-crowd ethics -- the kind of ethics that led many Germans to look away when the Nazi atrocities were being committed. But one doesn't need to embrace my utilitarian ethic to see that, at the very least, there is a troubling incongruity in being so quick to condemn Dora for taking the child to the organ peddlers while, at the same time, not regarding the American consumer's behavior as raising a serious moral issue. Unger called up some experts and used the information they provided to offer some plausible estimates that include the cost of raising money, administrative expenses and the cost of delivering aid where it is most needed. The child was a complete stranger to him and too far away to relate to in an intimate, personal way. For many years to come, Bob enjoys owning his Bugatti and the financial security it represents. Singer fails to mention how much people struggle in America alone. In addition to the pleasure he gets from driving and caring for his car, Bob knows that its rising market value means that he will always be able to sell it and live comfortably after retirement. At this point various objections may crop up. This is a large demand that does not convince people to want to donate their money. Think again about Bob and his Bugatti. Now Singer has said that he wants everyone to donate every cent of his or her extra money to charity.

Her neighbor spoils the fun, however, by telling her that the boy was too old to be adopted —he will be killed and his organs sold for transplantation. She would then have become, in the eyes of the audience, a monster. Suppose Dora had told her neighbor that it is a tough world, other people have nice new TV's too, and if selling the kid is the only way she can get one, well, he was only a street kid.

Singer adopts the persona of a sage utilitarian philosopher who judges the morality of actions based on the consequences that are wrought by them The consequence of Bob's action or more appropriately lack of action was the child died, so he acted wrongly according to Singer.

Your time is important.

Singer solution to world poverty essays

After initially reading these two articles the reader might think that these authors have two clearly different views on the matter of altruism. These situations are similar first of all because just as Bob did not know or could not see the child on the tracks, we do not know the child that will receive our donation.

What she has to do is persuade a homeless nine year old boy to go with her to an address she is given where he will be adopted by foreigners. Moving to a new house might not be a necessity, but it improves the life of a family that moved. Are you therefore obliged to keep giving until you have nothing left?

the singer solution to world poverty annotations

Suppose that there were more owners of priceless vintage cars —Carol, Dave, Emma, Fred and so on, down to Ziggy— all in exactly the same situation as Bob, with their own siding and their own switch, all sacrificing the child in order to preserve their own cherished car.

She delivers the boy, gets the money, spends some of it on a television set and settles down to enjoy her new acquisition.

singer vs hardin
Rated 6/10 based on 70 review
Download
Analysis of “The Singer Solution To World Poverty” Essay Example